Suicide Among Youths: A Study
"Even in young lives, silent pain speaks volumes."...Vishal Banga
Youth suicide in India is when young Indian people deliberately end their own
life. People aged 15 to 24 years have the highest suicide rate in India, which
is consistent with international trends in youth suicide, 35% of recorded
suicides in India occur in this age group. Risk factors and methods of youth
suicide differ from those in other age groups.
Introduction
The rise in suicides among Indian youth is a distressing phenomenon that demands
urgent attention. Recent years have seen a stark increase in such incidents,
indicating an underlying crisis that requires immediate examination. These
distressing statistics not only highlight individual tragedies but also raise
serious concerns about the societal, cultural, and systemic factors contributing
to this alarming trend.
Suicidal behaviours among young people in India are a major problem. An
understanding of the reasons for suicide attempts from survivor perspectives is
essential to developing suicide prevention programs for this population, as
these can provide valuable insights into concerns that are unique to young
people, and direct the focus of such programs towards these specific concerns.
Qualitative studies are best suited for eliciting such perspectives, but such
studies in India are lacking.
We conducted semi-structured interviews with 47 persons between the ages of 15
and 29 who had been admitted to a public hospital in Pune, India, following a
suicide attempt. Participants were asked to describe in their own words, what
they believed was the reason for the attempt. Data was analysed using inductive
thematic analysis and summative content analysis.
There were three broad factors that interacted to lead to suicide attempts:
background factors (individual and environmental factors that increased
vulnerability); psychological distress (emotional and cognitive states that led
to suicidal ideation); and intervening factors (factors that facilitated
transition from distress to the attempt). The most common pattern was the
occurrence of an interpersonal stressor shortly before the attempt, which
produced distorted cognitions, and overwhelming emotions - usually of anxiety or
anger - with ready access to means and/or impulsivity being the final catalysts.
This stressor was generally a trigger associated with long-standing problems
involving partners or family members, which had already produced intolerable
distress over time. Female participants appeared particularly vulnerable to
these stressors, partly due to prevailing socio-cultural norms. Our findings
suggest the need for suicide prevention programs in India to foster life skills
for young people, engage with high-risk groups (for example, women), and
restrict access to harmful substances. Family stakeholders need to be involved
in the implementation.
Societal Pressures and Expectations
Within Indian society, youth often grapple with immense pressure to conform to
societal expectations. Cultural norms and familial pressures frequently dictate
life choices, career paths, and personal relationships. The burden of fulfilling
familial obligations while striving to meet societal standards places an
overwhelming weight on the shoulders of young individuals. These expectations
often limit personal freedom and hinder the pursuit of one's authentic
aspirations, leading to mental health strain and, in extreme cases, suicidal
tendencies.
According to the National Crime Records Bureau data for 2021, 5,607 girls under
18 died by suicide as compared to 5,075 boys.
Psychiatrist Dr Harish Shetty said, "The NCRB data about more teenaged girls
than boys dying by suicide reflects the fact that girls experience more pressure
by parents and society to conform and also experience more violence in
relationships.'' He said girls are "blamed" for relationships when discovered by
parents who view it "as a loss of reputation.
Mental Health Challenges
In India, mental health concerns remain heavily stigmatized, especially among
the youth. Misconceptions and societal taboos surrounding mental health problems
discourage open discussions and seeking professional help. Limited accessibility
to mental health services further compounds this issue, leaving many young
individuals struggling in silence. The lack of awareness and acceptance of
mental health conditions contributes significantly to the rising suicide rates
among Indian youth.
Arjun Gupta, 25, had a troubled adolescence. All of 17 in 2015, Gupta had just
cleared the All India Pre-Medical Test (AIPMT), the predecessor of the National
Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET). For months, he studied 15 hours a
day-eight at school, five at a coaching institute, and two by himself:
"The pressure was immense, but finally I was going to join my dream college. It
was all going well. Then, suddenly, I was caught in a spiral of very negative
thoughts, about myself, my career, my choices."
The next 18 months were harrowing for Gupta; his thoughts turned to self-harm
and worse. He was diagnosed with depression but refused to accept it. "Emotions,
mental health, depression were all signs of weakness in my mind. Boys didn't
have such problems," he said. Over time, Gupta's parents started locking the
terrace door and hiding sharp objects at their home in Hisar, Haryana.
The turning point came when Gupta left a post on Facebook: "I wrote about what I
was going through, and the support that came my way felt like a game changer."
He tweaked his dream of becoming a doctor and trained as a psychologist instead.
NCRB formal role
The annual report on accidental deaths and suicides published by the National
Crimes Record Bureau (NCRB) does not tabulate the suffering that people like
Gupta go through. It only counts the attempts that resulted in death. According
to the most recent NCRB data, 13,089 students died by suicide in 2021, a 32.5
per cent jump compared to the 9,905 deaths in 2017. This amounts to nearly 36
student suicides in India every day of 2021.
Chennai-based psychiatrist Dr Lakshmi Vijayakumar founded Sneha, India's first
suicide prevention helpline, in 1986. Distilling the 2021 data, she told
Frontline that the reasons listed by NCRB, such as "love affair", "failure in
examination", "mental illness", and "family problems", may only be the final
trigger, the larger causes lie elsewhere.
A cry for help that goes unnoticed
Mental health issues, academic pressure, and social stigma are driving India's
students to suicide. What can we do to prevent it?
Students appear for the Class 12 board exam conducted by the Madhya Pradesh
Board of Secondary Education, in Bhopal.
Arjun Gupta, 25, had a troubled adolescence. All of 17 in 2015, Gupta had just
cleared the All India Pre-Medical Test (AIPMT), the predecessor of the National
Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET). For months, he studied 15 hours a
day-eight at school, five at a coaching institute, and two by himself: "The
pressure was immense, but finally I was going to join my dream college. It was
all going well. Then, suddenly, I was caught in a spiral of very negative
thoughts, about myself, my career, my choices."
The next 18 months were harrowing for Gupta; his thoughts turned to self-harm
and worse. He was diagnosed with depression but refused to accept it. "Emotions,
mental health, depression were all signs of weakness in my mind. Boys didn't
have such problems," he said. Over time, Gupta's parents started locking the
terrace door and hiding sharp objects at their home in Hisar, Haryana.
The turning point came when Gupta left a post on Facebook: "I wrote about what I
was going through, and the support that came my way felt like a game changer."
He tweaked his dream of becoming a doctor and trained as a psychologist instead.
The annual report on accidental deaths and suicides published by the National
Crimes Record Bureau (NCRB) does not tabulate the suffering that people like
Gupta go through. It only counts the attempts that resulted in death. According
to the most recent NCRB data, 13,089 students died by suicide in 2021, a 32.5
per cent jump compared to the 9,905 deaths in 2017. This amounts to nearly 36
student suicides in India every day of 2021.
India's pressure-cooker education system
While child and adolescent psychiatrist Dr Amit Sen believes the COVID-19
pandemic might explain some of these numbers from 2021, he told Frontline that
India anyway accounts for a large chunk of youth suicides worldwide despite the
gross underreporting. NCRB data reveal that of the 1,64,033 people who died by
suicide in India in 2021, 10,732 were below the age of 18, and 56,543 were in
the 18-30 age group. "We worry about how to prevent it, but what about the
emotional suffering kids go through to take that step? Are we blind to that?
There has been abject apathy," Sen said.
Sen, who is the co-founder of Children First, a mental health service
organisation in the Delhi-NCR region, believes distress is caused by a multitude
of factors: "Our approach is systemic and multidisciplinary; it addresses
various stakeholders. We focus on the family, the educational institution, the
developmental history. We engage with all these."A billboard announcing exam
toppers from a coaching centre in Kota. Such rankings add to student anxiety.
Author's brother Manoj Kumar having all adequate necessities in life suddenly
found hung with rope , the reasons of which yet are unreavealed and based on
presumptions only , belonging to Una district of Himachal Pradesh, further the
elaboration relies on sudden plans how it resulted into a life lost factor.
These are unnoticed cry which needs help;
Unnoticed cry for help
Manjot Chabra, who was enrolled at a NEET coaching institute in Kota, Rajasthan,
was found dead in his hostel roomlast month. Chabra left behind three sticky
notes. In one, he wished his father a happy birthday. He said "sorry" in
another, and in the third, he asked that his friends and parents not be
harassed. Back in his hometown, Uttar Pradesh's Rampur, Chabra had earned some
renown as a Class XII topper. His friends in Kota remember him as fun-loving and
driven, but they also said Chabra sometimes said he was "next in line", in the
context of the suicides happening in Kota.
Gupta is struck by how this cry for help from Chabra went unnoticed. "He was a
topper, and I once heard a Kota administrator say it's mostly the low scorers
who die by suicide."
Chennai-based psychiatrist Dr Lakshmi Vijayakumar founded Sneha, India's first
suicide prevention helpline, in 1986. Distilling the 2021 data, she told
Frontline that the reasons listed by NCRB, such as "love affair", "failure in
examination", "mental illness", and "family problems", may only be the final
trigger, the larger causes lie elsewhere.
Suicide, said Vijayakumar, must be understood through its intersectionality: "It
is determined by a combination of factors-biological, psychological, social,
environmental, religious, contextual." For instance, in the NCRB category of
"family problems" it could be disputes and conflict, financial strain, an
alcoholic parent, or sexual, emotional or physical abuse. "Exposure to violence
when you are young often leads to suicidal behaviour. Bullying and academic
pressure are also big determinants. Adolescents could also have issues relating
to sexual identity and orientation."
According to Arjun Kapoor, a research fellow at the Centre for Mental Health Law
& Policy (CMHLP), half of India's suicides are due to mental health issues while
"the remaining 50 per cent happen due to other factors and a lot are impulsive".
Youth can be a perilous and turbulent time in life. If young people have no one
to confide their distress in, they sometimes feel overwhelmed. "In a fit of
anger or distress, they end their life," Kapoor said.
According to a report published in The Lancet, the suicide rate recorded by the
NCRB is 37 per cent lower than that reported by the Global Burden of Disease.
Kapoor, who leads two of CMHLP's youth suicide prevention projects, believes
NCRB's data are unreliable because they underestimate the real extent of the
crisis. Equally, not all suicides are reported in India because of the attached
stigma.
Academic Stress
The educational landscape in India is renowned for its competitiveness.
Youngsters face relentless academic pressure, with success often being narrowly
defined by academic achievements. The intense competition, coupled with parental
and societal expectations for high performance, leads to stress, anxiety, and a
fear of failure among students. The immense pressure to excel academically
creates an environment where mental health is often overlooked or sacrificed for
the sake of meeting academic
Highlights
NCRB data show 13,089 students died by suicide in 2021, a 32.5 per cent jump
compared to the 9,905 deaths in 2017. This amounts to nearly 36 student suicides
in India every day of 2021. This emphasises the need to address the emotional
suffering that students endure before taking such drastic steps, highlighting
the lack of empathy and understanding regarding mental health issues.
Various factors contribute to the suicides: academic pressure, bullying,
discrimination, and societal expectations. The crisis highlights the importance
of early intervention, support systems, and destigmatising mental health issues
among students..
Lack of Support Systems
Despite the increasing prevalence of mental health challenges, the existing
support systems in India remain inadequate. Limited access to mental health
professionals, a shortage of counselling services, and the dearth of awareness
programs exacerbate the problem. The absence of proper infrastructure to address
mental health issues leaves young individuals grappling with their problems
without adequate guidance or support.
Recorded annual youth suicide rates in India are 80 per 100,000 in females and
34 per 100,000 in males (compared to 10.4 per 100,000 in the general Indian
population). These reported figures are estimated to be six- to eight-fold
under-estimates of the true incidence.
Surveys of high school students in India estimate prevalence at 6-22%, and of
suicide attempts at 0.39-8%.A survey conducted in 2009 found that 3.9% of young
people have exhibited some suicidal behavior.
Statistics show that suicide rates in the 15-29-year-old Indian men is twice the
global average, while rates in young Indian women is nearly 6 times as high. An
article in the May edition of 'SSM-Mental Health', an indexed medical journal,
talked to survivors of suicide attempts and made found "interpersonal stressors"
involving partners or family members (especially parents) were the primary
confers of suicide risk.
Parental support system can make a difference
Some young people are fortunate to have a strong parental support system. Ishita
Mehra, 28, remembers struggling with suicidal tendencies from the age of eight
or 10. The thoughts returned when Mehra faced bouts of depression, first in
2012, when she was 17, then two years later, when she went to a design school in
Delhi: "The brain sometimes felt so foggy that not a single bit of information
went through."
Her school counsellor was of little help, often dismissing concerns that were
brought to her. Mehra found comfort in her understanding mother and father.
Mehra said, "My dad doubled up as my therapist. He went through depression when
he was younger and used his experience to tell me 'You'll pull through it.
Conclusion and Solutions
The issue of escalating suicides among Indian youth necessitates immediate and
comprehensive action. Creating awareness and destigmatizing mental health
problems should be a priority. Implementing mental health education in schools,
establishing accessible counselling services, and promoting community support
networks are essential steps. Additionally, fostering an environment that
encourages open dialogue and acceptance of diverse aspirations can help
alleviate the societal pressures that contribute to mental health strain among
the youth.
This expanded outline provides a framework for diving deeper into the causes and
potential solutions surrounding the rising rates of suicides among Indian youth.
Are there specific details or aspects you'd like to focus on within these
sections?
Law Article in India
You May Like
Please Drop Your Comments